Current System:
| QUOTE |
| The video will be judges on smoothness, speed, difficulty, creativity, vareity and filming all out of five, and the totals from 3 judges will be used to decide the winner. |
Zombo's System:
Designed for team-spinning tournaments. Could easily be implimented, but the change may cause a few rough edges, would still use three judges.
http://z15.invisionfree.com/UCPSB/index.php?showtopic=5427P.S. Zombo, if we do change I would ned a finalized version of the rules asap, if anything was changed.
see the flaws in the current system reveals itself when you have multiple judges. while they all might see that one combo is say smoother than another, they still might give different rankings in smoothness on an absolute scale, depending on the judge.
using relative ranking it takes out alot of the human deviation in the judges
Omg... I thought this exact thing when I saw the ridiculous creativity scores on the last 000 battle...
Hell yeah it should change! Zombo's system is just clearly better in every way.
Very well. It seems that the oppinion is pretty clear. Hence forth the videos will be judged relatively, using Zombo's system. This will be implimented in the very next battle (including those that are already in progress, but have not been judged yet).
Thank you all for the oppinions.